Kerrydale Street-Refs & VAR Thread || Collum new Head of Refereeing || EPL will vote on removing VAR (2024)

Celtic Card wrote: ↑

6:44 PM - 6 days ago

Just remembered the handball penalty thing. Their player, can't remember who, leans into the ball. It hits his arm. His arm's by his side, but he leans into the flightpath of the ball. The type of penalty they get but no-one else does...

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

sterling

Jimmy_Quinn's_Hattrick wrote:The longer it takes for the kicker to take a penalty, the more likely he is to miss. I've always said this.

Stalling the penalty today was intentional. Targetted delaying tactic.

Definitely. He had some time to overthink things and get caught up in the moment.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Huns have went through the stages, sack the players, sack the manager, now they are onto the officials cheating them. One wanted not only the penalty overruled but a red card for MOR for simulation.

Funny af how many of them are arguing that its the same as Dessers on Lagerbielke and Morelos v Dortmund. All decisions that went against them.

Var has no business getting involved in that penalty, it was an absolute stonewaller and there was zero clear and obvious error there

That's the kind of thing we should be kicking up eff about

How collum misses that red card is beyond me and the leniency he showed the huns in the first 30 minutes was scandalous

They've come out of that game with zero bookings ffs

At one point we'd given away 6 fouls and had 3 bookings and they were on 14 fouls, obviously with no bookings

Another rdiculous day

Collum was at it in the first half especially. The huns should have had at least two bookings by first 25/30

Cheating to allow them to disrupt and hack with impunity. It has a huge impact on momentum

Franakamura wrote:

ParkheadsGates wrote: ↑

6:30 PM - 6 days ago

Fair play eff all.
Sorry mate.

Colum has no excuse for missing that in real time.

McLean had no option but to send him to the monitor.
VAR should have been looking at their goal, two hands on Taylors shoulders preventing him from jumping. As clear a foul as you'll ever see.
Why McLean felt the need to get involved in a stonewall penalty is beyond explanation.

Said it at the time, Colum missing that in real time as a red is a sacking offence.

He missed a very similar one in a game against Motherwell a season or two back , difference in that game was var didn’t even look at it that time

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Pennywisethecelt wrote: ↑

10:20 PM - 6 days ago

Jimmy_Quinn's_Hattrick wrote:The longer it takes for the kicker to take a penalty, the more likely he is to miss. I've always said this.

Stalling the penalty today was intentional. Targetted delaying tactic.

Definitely. He had some time to overthink things and get caught up in the moment.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

In American Football this is so well understood that there's a concept known as 'icing the kicker'. Let's say it's a tight game which is nearly over, and the kicker has come on to potentially score the winning field goal. It's quite far out or the weather is poor so it's a difficult shot. The other team may take a timeout just a few seconds before they're about to kick. Adds a few minutes for the kicker to think about the high pressure kick too much, disrupts their flow etc.

No need for the defending teams to worry about that in football because we have VAR doing it for them!

Diomande wasn't booked in that whole game.

Outrageous.

MON's Left Eyebrow wrote:Diomande wasn't booked in that whole game.

Outrageous.

No hun was

KrnyBhoy wrote: ↑

4:59 AM - 6 days ago

MON's Left Eyebrow wrote:Diomande wasn't booked in that whole game.

Outrageous.

No hun was

Lundstram was.

That was the level he was looking for before booking a hun: a literal straight red card potentially career ending foul...

Mr Stein wrote: ↑

2:55 PM - 6 days ago

How long was the wait between the penalty being awarded and MOR taking it? A farce that it took so long. Butland should also have been booked for his shenanigans. Can't really blame Matt too much given these ridiculous set of circ*mstances.

As much as our penalty stats are terrible; no one is going to convince me that Brother McLean did not intervene in that penalty decision other than to spin it out and seed doubt with Collum and O’Riley. It was a last throw of the Masonic dice from that sneaky Hun.

paddysloan wrote: ↑

3:05 AM - 6 days ago

Was never a pen. O’Reilly’s stuck the foot in and taken a swan dive. I’d be effin fuming if that was given at the other end.
Lundstrum’s was a stonewall red, he nearly broke AJ’s ankle ffs. It’s a travesty that carrot Miller played for us.

If you think that wasn't a pen, football's not for you man

paddysloan wrote: ↑

3:05 AM - 6 days ago

Was never a pen. O’Reilly’s stuck the foot in and taken a swan dive. I’d be effin fuming if that was given at the other end.
Lundstrum’s was a stonewall red, he nearly broke AJ’s ankle ffs. It’s a travesty that carrot Miller played for us.

Don't agree with that at all. Matt had been hitting everything and was winding up to strike the ball again and gets clipped.

We really need to go back on the VAR process. From the amount of time checking the own goal, the penalty and then those checks that stopped us taking quick goal kicks when they were out of position. Almost like every intervention (except the red card) was intended to work against us.

Masterplanner wrote: ↑

7:11 AM - 5 days ago

paddysloan wrote: ↑

3:05 AM - 6 days ago

Was never a pen. O’Reilly’s stuck the foot in and taken a swan dive. I’d be effin fuming if that was given at the other end.
Lundstrum’s was a stonewall red, he nearly broke AJ’s ankle ffs. It’s a travesty that carrot Miller played for us.

If you think that wasn't a pen, football's not for you man

was thinking that myself. It was a small clip from behind, that broke OReillys running action and he kicked the ground. Clear penalty. In fact more of a Penalty than the one var gave in the last game.
I shouted red card on the Lundstrums tackle when i saw it live. Was as clear as a player going in out of control as you could get (unless your name is Kenny). how a prof ref missed that or bottled making the decision I will never know. We have lots of previous experience from Collum with people doing lunges as our players without penalty in the past.

The Sevilliano wrote: ↑

11:09 PM - 6 days ago

Collum was at it in the first half especially. The huns should have had at least two bookings by first 25/30

Cheating to allow them to disrupt and hack with impunity. It has a huge impact on momentum

The first 25?
Diamande committed two bookables in the first 11 minutes (the benefit of the clock on the big screen).

Then there were the obligatory fouls by Silva and Lawrence.

Giving cloggers encouragement never works.
You always end up having to show a red card.